Voodoo and Treme: We Do What We Need To

Black night is falling. The stars are incredibly close. Jack White is mining the past to an adoring crowd in City Park. The Saints are being crushed in Denver. I’m heading to Buffa’s to watch Treme.

I’m really torn by what I witnessed at the Voodoo Experience. I want to thank Neil Young and Crazy Horse for playing the best or maybe second best show of the twenty-something I’ve seen by them over the years. Only the Madison Square Garden Rust Never Sleeps show was on the level of what happened Friday night. Others of course have their own moments. But those who were obsessed with Young’s age completely missed the point. Neil Young and Crazy Horse put it all on the line Friday night. They gave us everything they had and they have plenty. During “Walk Like A Giant,” Young kept turning to the band and shouting for more, punching both arms emphatically in the air like Charlton Heston in The Ten Commandments parting the Red Sea. He wanted more and he got it. Nothing was left behind when they finished. The grandeur of the coda, where Young got Crazy Horse to mimic the sound of a giant walking in immense, crushing strides for what seemed like 10 minutes, was truly astonishing.

Young was not fooling around. He threw the gauntlet immediately with “Love and Only Love” from the critically undervalued Crazy Horse masterpiece Ragged Glory.

“Love and only love will endure… Hate is everything you think it is.”

The raw, open-hearted emotion that Young can bring to a song is best served in this anthem to unabashed passion, to following your heart at all costs. Call him a hippie and he’ll cop to that with a chip on his shoulder. You got a better solution, Mitt?

And “Fucking Up,” another Ragged Glory track, what a moment. You think this is about drugs? It’s about you fucking up getting the meaning of the song, bro. It’s about me making every mistake in the book. It’s about all the times Neil’s father took him down a notch. And it’s about getting off the floor and trying your best the next time. Let’s all sing along to our folly and move on.

“Ramada Inn” may be the best song Neil’s ever written. It’s simplicity and complexity, redemption and the horror of the abyss, all at once. And of course the saving grace is love. What else do we have, ever? “She loved him so… she did what she had to.”

A close friend told me this set changed her life. Truth.

At other points Voodoo left me wanting to run away screaming. The sound was often so bad, bleeding so intensely from stage to stage. I want to offer a personal apology to anyone who went to see AWOLNATION on my recommendation. I based that pick on recordings, but the band sucked the tailpipe so hard in person I was left aghast. And the abomination of the Red Bull stage was truly appalling. Has Dev gotten here yet? I mean, the Preservation Hall stage ran like the German rail road but it seemed nobody played at Le Plur when they were supposed to. Of course everybody was so jacked on ecstasy they didn’t care as featureless automorons spun aural wallpaper for the stunned denizens. Frank Zappa had an apt description for this. It’s not music, it’s “lifestyle accessory.” And of course it’s the future of pop, of course. Pop is supposed to reflect mass culture, and American culture is becoming so completely homogenized that it’s inevitable it will sound like this for the forseeable future.

As for the future of Voodoo, the sparse crowds indicated that the once vast chasm in booking philosophy between the Jazz and Heritage Festival and Voodoo has dwindled to a razor’s edge. Jack White has played Jazz Fest, as has Young. That leaves Metallica, which isn’t much of an edge. Voodoo still skews younger than Jazz Fest but there’s really not as much variety and when the mainstream rock support acts are as bad as this year’s bunch the edge disappears completely.

Over at Buffa’s, sitting in the back room watching Treme with an audience of people who populate the screen in front of you is an experience that offers a stark contrast to the mall of Voodoo. Treme is showing us what is happening to our culture. New Orleans, a city full of creative people — not just musicians and artists but artisans of every stripe, metal workers with soul and street sweepers who are honored in their community — is being remade in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. As Desiree points out incredulously in episode six, “Careless Love,” as she looks at the empty lot where her house once stood, “It’s like they don’t want us to come back.” For Desiree “us” is the African American community, but anyone who lives as an artist is part of what’s endangered here. In Treme the vision of city planners is to institutionalize culture and literally corral it — in Armstrong Park for the proposed jazz center, but also in City Park for Voodoo, at the Fair Grounds (or perhaps City Park in the future) for Jazz Fest, or elsewhere as long as it can be tagged with a dog collar. But definitely not on the streets, at the second lines, in the neighborhoods, or the corner bars where music grew and is still nurtured. All that is under siege. Our future is endangered, and nobody is going to help us except ourselves. If we don’t listen to Neil Young and do what we have to, do what we need to, we’re going to lose everything that matters to us.

–John Swenson

  • http://www.facebook.com/brian.b.mccolgan Brian B McColgan

    You are so right John. There is something about Voodoo that is missing and calling it the mall of Voodoo is spot on. While Jazzfest and Bonnaroo are also manufactured events, they somehow possess some resonance that you have just experienced something special. And while Voodoo claims it is an “experience” and not a festival, it’s end result is the opposite. Neil Young, however, transcended all of that and left me feeling like I just made the spiritual pilgrimage of my lifetime. And I’ll always have my ringing ears as a memento.

    • Iko

      “But definitely not on the streets, at the second lines, in the
      neighborhoods, or the corner bars where music grew and is still
      nurtured. All that is under siege. Our future is endangered, and nobody
      is going to help us except ourselves.”

      This is true, and we have to work hard to preserve the incubator of New Orleans music. It’s what makes us what we are.

      However, this year’s Voodoo fest, even with its sparse attendance and marginal weather, was a very satisfying musical experience for me. I saw Star
      & Dagger, Paul Sanchez and the Cast of 9 Lives, New Orleans
      Nightingales, Gary Clark Jr. (he’s one of the best live acts I’ve seen in years), Supagroup, Avett Bros, Pimps of Joytime,
      Bootsy Collins (on his birthday), Debauche (the self-described “Russian Mafia Band”), Fleur de Tease/White Beach Prince
      Tribute (a truly amazing performance!), Chicano Batman, Zeale, Dave Stewart (with Soul Rebels for last 2
      incredible songs, “Would I Lie to You” and “Sweet Dreams”), Soul Rebels (including covers of Metallica and
      Eurythmics), Toots & the Maytals, Anders Osborne (with Johnny
      Sansone & Monk Boudreaux), Justice, Metallica, Dash Rip Rock (with Glenn Tilbrook of Squeeze), Royal
      Teeth, Sexdog, Tangiers Blues Band, Lost Bayou Ramblers (one of the best sets of the Fest), Preservation
      Hall Jazz Band (ditto), The New Orleans Bingo Show and Jack White, among others.

      As you noted, Neil Young & Crazy Horse were transcendent. Perhaps they should have closed the festival. Their show alone was worth the price of a 3-day admission.

      Thanks for your thoughtful piece. Very well done. I like music in City Park and at Napoleon and Tchoupitoulas and the French Quarter and Frenchman and St. Claude and Carrollton Ave. everywhere else. We need to keep it all alive.